Ivona MikulčićNovember 27, 20257 min readLast update: Oct 7, 2026
How to Get Competitors' Clients with Cold Outreach (Cold Email Teardown)
Your competitors’ clients are the warmest cold leads you will ever write to. They already pay money to solve the exact problem you solve. They already sat through a demo, built a business case, and convinced their boss. Someone else just got there first. So when I look at a list of accounts running a competing tool, I don’t see a locked door. I see a renewal date.
In this post, I’ll show you exactly how to find and win your competitors’ clients with cold outreach. We’ll go through where to pull the list, a real cold email that booked meetings with mid to C-level users of competing software, the line-by-line rewrite that made it better, and the follow-up cadence I’d run around it. One tweak in that rewrite, mentioning a colleague by name, pulled 5-10x more replies for the agency that sent it.
Where to find your competitors’ clients
Most articles on this topic skip straight to the email. That’s the fun part. It’s also useless if your list is wrong. Here are the methods that actually work, including the ones that have nothing to do with us.
Review sites. G2 and Capterra are public confession booths. People leave their job title, their company, and a paragraph explaining what they hate about the product they bought. Sort your competitor’s page by lowest rating and read the complaints. You now have named buyers, their pain, and their words.
Tech-stack lookups. Tools like BuiltWith or Wappalyzer tell you which companies run a given script, tag, or platform. Great for anything with a web footprint. Weaker for back-office software that never touches the front end.
LinkedIn Sales Navigator. Filter by job title, headcount, and keywords, then cross-reference with people who follow your competitor’s page, comment on their posts, or list the tool in their profile skills. Slow, manual, and surprisingly accurate.
Job posts and community threads. A posting that asks for “3 years of [competitor] experience” tells you the stack. So does a Slack or subreddit thread where someone asks how to work around a limitation.
All four work. All four are manual. The reason I stopped doing them one at a time is volume: by the time I’d built a 200-account list by hand, half of it had gone quiet. Inside lemlist you can filter accounts by tech stack and pull verified contacts from the same screen, which turns a week of tab-switching into an afternoon.
Then there’s timing, which matters more than the list itself. A company that renewed last month is not a buyer. A company whose head of ops just resigned, or that quietly dropped a tool from its stack, is. lemlist’s intent signals track when competitors’ clients are ready to switch by watching tech-stack changes, hiring changes, funding rounds, job changes, website visits, and LinkedIn engagement. That’s the research step, automated, so you’re writing to accounts that already moved.
Cold email insights to book more meetings
Here’s a cold email that targets mid to C-level employees using competitors’ software. It comes from devlo, an agency that runs this play for its clients. You can read devlo’s full lemlist case study if you want the numbers behind it.
Five reasons this one gets replies:
Tip #1: It shows research
The first sentence is personalized with the names of the competitor tools the account uses, which proves the sender understands the lead’s setup before asking for anything.
Tip #2: There’s a “what if” question
These questions prompt people to picture themselves in a situation where their pain point is already fixed. You’re selling the after, not the product.
Tip #3: It mentions clients
Name-dropping clients who look like your lead, with a clear before and after, does the credibility work for you. A small concession here: if you name a direct competitor of theirs, it can land as a threat instead of proof. Pick a company in an adjacent industry at a similar size, and the same line reads as reassurance.
Tip #4: There’s an interest-based CTA
Before you ask for a meeting, use the first email to confirm interest and build rapport. Lower the ask, raise the reply rate.
Tip #5: It’s short
Around 80 words. Short enough to read on a phone between meetings, which is where most of these get opened.
How to write a cold email for a high conversion rate
Hungry for more? Here’s how that same email gets rewritten for better results.
Tip #1: Use liquid syntax
Use liquid syntax to write one email that adapts to each lead’s attributes and opens with a time-appropriate greeting. Good for deliverability, better for personalization at scale.
Tip #2: Describe clear pain points
Spell out the pain instead of hinting at it. A lead who recognizes their own Monday morning in your second sentence will read the third.
Tip #3: Mention a colleague
Go to LinkedIn and find a colleague in the same team, department, or company if it’s small. This is the single change that drove 5-10x more replies in devlo’s campaigns. Doing it by hand for 300 leads is miserable, so automate LinkedIn research and outreach and let the visits, invites, and messages run alongside the email.
Tip #4: Use only 1 CTA
One option, one next step, zero friction. Two asks is the same as no ask.
Tip #5: Use more spacing
Add space between paragraphs. The message gets scannable and the value line stops hiding in a wall of text.
Tip #6: Scale the variants with AI
One good email is a lucky draw. What you want is the same angle written four ways and tested across the whole competitor list. lemAgent builds the sequence around your offer and your list, and smart messaging rewrites each variant against the lead’s role, industry, and stack. You keep the structure from the teardown. The machine handles the 300 permutations.
Cold email template to replicate for more replies
{% assign ampm = “now” | date: “%P” %}{% if ampm contains “am” %}Good morning{% else %}Good afternoon{% endif %} {{firstName}},
Noticed [Company] uses [Competitor] and [Competitor]. Using these, our clients were losing hours trying to get info out of their system for reporting.
Imagine if you could access and translate your essential business data in near real-time.
[Past client name], CIO at [Other company] went from 4 hours to around 3-4 seconds to gather information from JDE (his words, not ours).
[Name], are you or your colleague [FirstName LastName] open to see if we can do the same for you
LinkedIn connection note variant
Email is one door. The LinkedIn note is the other, and it works best sent the day before the email lands so your name is already familiar.
Hi {{firstName}}, saw [Company] runs [Competitor]. We rebuilt reporting for a few teams on the same stack and cut data pulls from hours to seconds. Happy to share what we did, no pitch.
Max 2 sentences. No exclamation marks. No link in the invite.
The 2-touch follow-up
Almost nobody replies to touch one, and almost nobody follows up. That gap is the whole opportunity.
Day 3, email: one sentence of new information, not a bump. A metric, a short client result, a relevant change in their stack. End with the same single CTA.
Day 7, LinkedIn message: reference the email once, then close the loop. “Still worth 15 minutes, or should I leave it?” Permission to say no gets you answers either way.
Run both channels from the same sequence so a reply anywhere stops every other touch. That’s what multichannel sequences are for. If you want more angles to test against this one, there are more cold email templates to pull from.
How to run this in lemlist
Four steps, start to finish.
Build the list. Filter the Lead Database by your competitors’ tech stack, headcount, and job titles. Export the accounts that match.
Enrich it. Pull verified emails, phone numbers, and LinkedIn profiles, then add the colleague name you’ll use in the “are you or your colleague” line.
Sequence it. LinkedIn visit, connection note, email with liquid syntax, follow-up email, LinkedIn message. Let smart messaging adapt each variant to the lead.
Track and react. Watch replies in the unified inbox, and let intent signals push accounts into the campaign the moment their stack or their team changes.
lemlist is rated 4.6/5 with 2,000+ reviews on G2, and this workflow is the one most of those users are running.
The key takeaways
Personalize with competitor tool names to show you did the research.
Pose a “what if” scenario that frames your solution against their pain point.
Name-drop similar clients with a clear before and after to build credibility.
Use a single, concise, interest-based CTA to start a conversation instead of demanding a meeting.
Mention a colleague and follow up twice, on two channels.
You can watch the complete cold email teardown here!
PS: Want more tips? Request outbound experts to review your cold emails here!
Over to you
Stealing clients from competitors is not a copywriting trick. The email matters, and it matters a lot less than writing to the right 200 accounts at the moment their patience runs out. Build the list first. Time it to a signal. Then send the short, researched, one-CTA email you just read, and follow up twice.
Pick one competitor this week and build the account list. Everything after that is execution.
Find your next outbound tool
Discover a better way to find leads and run multichannel campaigns with lemlist.