Throughout my career, I have created or assisted in creating over 30 commission plans for BDRs, SDRs, AEs, Sales Managers, VPs of Sales, and even CROs.
In this article, I will share my insights and give you a step-by-step process to define the structure of your next commission plan.
When it comes to sales, there's no denying the power of a strong incentive.
The reality is, sales is a tough gig.
Your team is on the front lines, overcoming objections, building relationships, and closing deals.
In this challenging environment, a well-structured commission plan can be just motivation they need to push harder, and deliver results that impact your bottom line.
A good commission plan is about creating a framework that encourages and rewards the right behaviors.
If it's too easy, it won't push your sales team hard enough. Too harsh, and it could discourage them. The goal is to find the right balance that motivates your team to not only reach but exceed their sales goals.
Remember, a commission plan isn't created for the finance or ops teams – it's created for sales. It's about leveraging the best habits and behaviors that will drive sales success.
A common pitfall is overcomplicating the rules, ending up with a 20-page document.
Not only is this confusing for your sales team, but it also creates unnecessary friction when it comes to implementation.
Your commission plan should be simple, straightforward, and easily explainable in 3 minutes – think of it as the '5-year-old test'. If a 5-year-old can get it, you're on the right track.
A commission plan isn't just about rewarding sales – it should reflect your company's priorities.
Selling multi-year contracts? Prioritizing upfront payment? Launching a new product or targeting a specific customer category?
Your commission plan should incentivize these behaviors.
By adjusting the commission rates, you can guide your team toward the goals that matter most to your business.
You want to hit that 'just right' balance.
Too generous, and you might put a strain on your resources. Too stingy, and you risk demotivating your sales team.
A fair commission plan rewards good performance, fosters motivation, and maintains harmony within your organization.
In the following sections, you'll get a step-by-step process to design your own sales commission plan that's simple, fair, motivating, and aligned with your business goals.
On-Target Earnings, or OTE, is the total compensation that a salesperson can expect to earn when they meet 100% of their sales quota. It consists of their fixed base salary plus potential commission.
For instance, a salesperson with a base salary of $100,000 and an equal amount in potential commission would have an OTE of $200,000. If they hit their quota, they essentially double their base salary.
The potential commission is tied to the salesperson's quota, or their annual sales goal. This quota measures their performance and determines their commission.
Continuing with our example, if the salesperson's OTE is $200,000 and their quota is $1 million in Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR), they'd need to hit that $1 million mark to double their base salary.
If they fall short, their commission shrinks proportionally. If they exceed it – that's where accelerators come in, but more on that later.
Even though this might seem basic, it's an essential first step. Defining the right OTE and sales quota can set the tone for your entire commission plan.
The base commission rate is the core of your commission structure.
It doesn't involve any accelerators, decelerators, or thresholds. Nor does it take into account particular incentives like selling multi-year contracts, obtaining upfront payments, or launching new products. These additional elements will come into play later.
The base commission rate offers a simple, straightforward benchmark that your salespeople can understand and work towards, and your finance department can effortlessly calculate.
Divide the target variable pay by the sales quota.
If you have a salesperson with an OTE of $200,000 (made up of a $100,000 base salary plus $100,000 in potential commission) and a sales quota of $1 million, the base commission rate is calculated as follows:
Base Commission Rate = Target Variable Pay / Sales Quota = $100,000 / $1,000,000 = 10%
So, in this case, the base commission rate is 10%.
Sales priorities should align with your company's overall objectives.
Are you launching a new product? If so, driving sales for that product becomes a priority.
Expanding into a new market? It's the same story.
If your goal is to boost upfront cash flow, securing upfront payments can be a priority.
Here are some examples of common sales priorities that can be reflected in your commission plan:
You might consider adding factors such as the presence of a Sales Development Representative (SDR) or Business Development Representative (BDR) on a deal. However, I advise caution. This can lead to undesirable behavior and conflicts of interest.
It's generally more effective to reward those who have contributed to the deal, but keep the commission percentage consistent for the salesperson, regardless of whether an SDR or BDR was involved.
Avoid factors such as sales seniority as sales priorities. Your base salary structure should already account for this, and a sale's value shouldn't depend on the seniority of the salesperson who closed the deal.
In practice, you should select one or two priorities each year to focus on.
For each priority, you'll define how to adjust the base commission rate when contracts meet the specified criteria. We'll delve into the specifics of this in the next step.
After identifying one or two key priorities for your sales team that align with your broader business goals, the next step is to clearly define objectives for each of these priorities.
The purpose of this step is to translate your priorities into tangible, measurable goals.
By setting specific objectives, you make it easier for your sales team to understand what they need to achieve and how their efforts will contribute to the company's overall success.
A practical approach to defining objectives is to think in terms of percentages of total sales.
For example, if your priority is to increase the sale of multi-year contracts, consider what percentage of total sales you want these contracts to represent.
To do this, you'll need to look at your historical data and have a conversation with your sales leadership team about what's achievable.
Let's say you've historically sold about 10% of multi-year contracts, but you'd like to push this up to 20% for the next year. If your total sales objective is $1 million, that means you're expecting 20% of that - or $200,000 - to come from multi-year contracts.
Remember, the goals you set for each of your priorities should be SMART: Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. In this example, your SMART goal might be: "Increase the revenue from multi-year contracts to $200,000 by the end of the fiscal year."
Once you've defined the objectives for one priority, repeat the process for the other. The key is to be clear and explicit about what you're expecting from your sales team.
This is a crucial step in your commission plan.
By clearly defining the objectives for each priority, you're setting your sales team up for success, aligning their efforts with your business strategy, and ensuring that their hard work will directly contribute to your company's most important goals. A well-defined target is much easier to hit.
The final step is to define the commission rate that will be paid out to the reps, based on what is sold.
This aspect of your commission plan is key to its success, as it directly impacts how frequently your sales team can expect to receive their incentives, which influences their motivation and performance.
While sales objectives are usually defined on a yearly basis, some companies opt for a more variable approach, with objectives that change each quarter.
However, it's worth noting that frequently changing objectives can require a substantial amount of maintenance and can potentially lead to confusion or frustration within your sales team.
A more practical approach might be to set yearly objectives, which can be broken down into quarters or months to accommodate for seasonal variations in your sales cycle.
For example, if your business tends to be slower in August and busier in December, you might want to adjust your monthly sales targets accordingly.
Example of Seasonality:
An important aspect of your commission plan is the frequency at which commissions are paid out. It's often beneficial to pay commissions as frequently as possible as this can drive salespeople's motivation and focus on shorter-term goals.
However, factors such as the length of your sales cycle might prevent you from making monthly commission payments.
As a rule of thumb, it's good practice to align commission payments with your sales cycle, but avoid extending the commission period beyond a quarter.
Example of Commission Payment Frequency Based on Sales Cycle:
Here, ACV stands for Annual Contract Value, which refers to the average yearly contract revenue from each contracted customer.
Another good practice is to pay commissions whenever deals are signed, and then calculate accelerators or decelerators (which we will discuss later) at the end of each commission period.
This approach essentially treats these payments as an advance on the commission, but it allows your sales team to be rewarded more immediately for their hard work, which can drive motivation and performance.
Commission periods can be different from commission payment schedules.
For instance, you might have quarterly plans with quarterly objectives, but monthly payments that function as an advance based on bookings.
A threshold is the minimum level of sales that a salesperson needs to achieve before they start earning commission. Some companies set the threshold at a level that covers the cost of the salesperson.
For example, if a salesperson is paid $100K per year and costs $125K including overheads, they will start receiving commission once they achieve $125K in sales.
However, while this approach may be logical from a financial perspective, it can potentially reduce the motivation of salespeople.
The reason is, it could lead to behaviors such as "fridge" deals, where salespeople delay closing deals until the next period if they anticipate they won't reach the threshold in the current period.
This can delay revenue and even result in lost deals. Hence, it's generally recommended to avoid using thresholds.
Acceleration and deceleration in a sales commission plan refer to increasing or decreasing the commission rate based on quota attainment.
A common method to implement this is by creating a table that correlates quota attainment ranges with commission rates.
Example of Acceleration/Deceleration Table:
The next step is deciding whether the acceleration or deceleration applies to the entire commission or just the base rate. For simplicity, it's generally recommended to apply it to the entire commission.
Here's an example:
Now let's look at two methods of applying the acceleration:
Finally, keep in mind that accelerations and decelerations can be applied in bulk or in tiers.
While bulk is simpler and avoids the need to track sales within different ranges, it can create threshold effects where a slight increase in sales leads to a significant jump in commission.
As always, simplicity is key, and it's important to remember that no commission plan can be perfect.
Creating the right commission plan involves multiple steps, from defining objectives to setting up acceleration or deceleration scales. The final step in this process is to articulate this plan effectively and concisely.
The goal is to provide a transparent and easily understandable document that guides your sales team and eliminates room for interpretation.
This document will be a formal and legal binding contract between the company and the salesperson.
Here are some considerations for writing the commission plan:
Now let's see a template for a Sales Commission Plan:
You can consider using the following mechanisms
→ Churn Clawback is a mechanism that enables you to recover paid commissions if a customer churns within a specified period of time.
For instance, you can set up a Commission Clawback for any churn within the first 3 or 6 months after the signature.
Be careful, as Churn Clawback needs to be well-defined regarding how it's calculated.
There are three possible methods:
→ "SPIFF" (Sales Program Incentive Funds) allows for rewarding specific behaviors or outcomes over a specific time frame.
For instance, you can decide on quarterly SPIFFs to reward new opportunities opened in the automotive industry.
SPIFFs are usually on top of regular commissions and aim to reward behaviors expected over a short period of time.
→ "Commission Draw" is a pre-defined amount of money that a newly hired Salesrep is given against future commissions.
Commission draw allows sales to maintain a certain level of income when changing jobs. There are two reasons why Commission Draws exist:
This is why it's common practice, particularly when hiring senior salespeople, to offer a commission draw.
The draw can be either recoverable or non-recoverable.
A non-recoverable draw guarantees a minimum commission for the Salesperson, while a recoverable draw means they need to pay back the amount over time.
I recommend using recoverable draws as they encourage Salespeople to perform well. On the other hand, non-recoverable draws do not incentivize Salespeople to perform their best.
For more details and examples, check out this article.
That concludes our discussion on Commission Plans. I hope you found this article helpful. If you have any questions or comments, please don't hesitate to contact me directly at firstname.lastname@example.org.
And... as promised, you can find the free template to get you started here!