Rémi KokabiNovember 19, 20266 min read

Who replies to cold outreach? Reply rates by seniority and department

A VP gets your cold email and ignores it. A manager on the same team reads the same pitch and replies within the hour. That gap shows up in every market lemlist has data on: individual contributors reply at 5.6% in Europe, VPs at 3.1%.

The cold email reply rate by job title tells you exactly where to spend your first move. HR and sales teams reply more than any other department. IT replies least. Seniority matters, but function matters just as much.

In this article, I’ll break down reply rates by seniority and department, explain why VPs and C-levels engage less, and show you who to target first inside an account. You’ll also learn when skipping the doer and going straight to the top actually works.

Get this right and you stop wasting sequence steps on people who were never going to answer.

Reply rates by seniority

Reply rates drop as seniority rises, and the gap changes by market. US prospects reply less across every level, but the rank order stays the same.

Seniority

Europe

US

Rest of world

Individual contributor

5.6%

3.5%

5.6%

Founder or owner

5.9%

3.5%

4.6%

Manager

4.1%

2.9%

4.3%

Head or director

3.5%

2.2%

3.5%

C-level

3.7%

2.1%

3.2%

VP

3.1%

2.0%

2.8%

Source: lemlist internal data from its users.

Founders are the exception. In Europe, campaigns that reach founders or owners reply at 5.9%, the highest of any seniority band. That number drops to 3.5% in the US and 4.6% in the rest of the world, but founders still outperform directors, C-levels, and VPs in every market.

VPs are the hardest group to get a reply from regardless of geography. If your ideal customer profile points to a VP, plan for more touches and a tighter message.

Reply rates by department

Some departments are more receptive to outbound than others. The gap between the top and bottom is almost double.

Department

Reply rate (all markets)

HR and people

5.6%

Sales

5.1%

Founders and general management

4.8%

Marketing

4.5%

Operations

4.0%

Finance

3.2%

IT and engineering

2.9%

Source: lemlist internal data from its users.

HR and sales professionals reply at roughly twice the rate of IT and engineering. That makes sense: HR and sales teams evaluate new vendors as part of their job. IT teams get buried in support tickets and internal requests, and cold outreach competes with a longer queue.

If you sell into multiple departments, use persona-based messaging to match the pain point to the function. A generic pitch sent to both an HR director and a CTO will underperform in both inboxes.

Why VPs and C-levels reply less

Three dynamics work against you when you email senior executives.

First, they receive more outbound. A VP of Sales at a mid-market SaaS company can get a high volume of cold emails per week. Volume alone pushes reply rates down.

Second, they spend less time in their inbox. Their calendars are filled with internal meetings, board prep, and cross-functional reviews. An email that lands at the wrong hour gets buried before they scroll back to it.

Third, they are further from the day-to-day problem your product solves. A VP approves the budget, but a manager or IC lives inside the workflow. The person who feels the friction is the one who reads your email and thinks “this is worth a reply.” The person who signs the contract often needs that internal champion to surface the conversation first.

None of this means you should never email a VP or C-level. It means your message has to earn its place in a thinner window of attention, with a sharper reason to respond.

Who to target first in an account

Start with the doer. That is the person who runs the process your product improves, usually a manager or individual contributor. They understand the problem, they can evaluate whether your solution fits, and they reply at a higher rate.

Then add the decision-maker in CC. Campaigns that CC a second stakeholder see +23% replies across all markets, according to lemlist internal data from its users. The CC line creates social proof inside the account: the doer sees their boss is aware, and the boss sees someone on their team is being approached with a relevant solution.

This is multi-threading in sales at its simplest. You open two doors with one email. The doer replies because the message speaks to their workflow. The decision-maker stays in the loop without needing to act.

A few guidelines for picking the right doer:

  • Look at who would use your product daily, not who would sign the contract

  • Match the job title to the problem your first email describes

  • If you sell to marketing teams, email the demand gen manager before the CMO

  • If you sell to sales teams, email the SDR lead or sales ops manager before the VP of Sales

When to go straight to the top

There are situations where skipping the doer makes sense.

In small companies, the founder often is the doer. They handle vendor decisions, run the process, and control the budget. Emailing a mid-level manager who does not exist wastes a sequence step.

Founder-led companies operate the same way even at larger headcounts. When the CEO still owns product direction or sales strategy, they are the right first contact. You can read more about how to structure that outreach in our guide on how to email a CEO.

In enterprise accounts, go to the top only when you have a strong signal. A signal could be a funding round, a leadership change, a public initiative that maps to your product, or a hiring pattern that reveals a new priority. Without that signal, a cold email to a Fortune 500 CRO will disappear. With it, you have a reason to be in their inbox that separates you from the noise.

lemlist intent signals track events like funding rounds, job changes, tech stack shifts, and hiring activity, then surface leads when the timing is right. That signal context feeds directly into your campaign, and the message explains why you are reaching out now, not last month.

Final takeaway

Target the person closest to the problem. CC the person who controls the budget. Use department and seniority data to prioritize which accounts get your best sequences first.

The data is consistent across markets: individual contributors and managers reply more than VPs and C-levels. HR and sales teams reply more than IT and finance. Build your outreach around those patterns instead of defaulting to the highest title you can find.

Build your first signal-based sequence in lemlist.

Find data about your leads

Discover prospects and enrich their data to launch targeted campaigns.

Frequently asked questions

Start with managers. They reply at higher rates, with campaigns reaching managers in Europe seeing 4.1% compared to 3.1% for VPs, according to lemlist internal data from its users. Managers work closer to the problem your product solves. Once a manager engages, loop in the executive for budget approval.

HR and people teams reply at 5.6% across all markets, followed by sales at 5.1%, according to lemlist internal data from its users. IT and engineering reply least at 2.9%. Tailor your messaging to the department’s priorities rather than sending the same pitch to every function.

Yes. Campaigns that CC a second stakeholder see +23% replies across all markets, according to lemlist internal data from its users. The VP does not need to reply themselves. Their presence in the CC line adds weight and signals that the conversation matters beyond the individual recipient.

Map the account by function and seniority. Identify who runs the process you improve (the doer) and who approves the spend (the decision-maker). lemlist’s lead database of 650M+ contacts with filters by role, seniority, and department helps you build that map fast. For a full walkthrough, see our guide on finding decision makers.
Rémi Kokabi

Rémi Kokabi

Co-founder @GTM Club

Share this post