Rémi KokabiNovember 19, 20266 min read

What the top 10% of outbound campaigns do differently (lemlist data)

14.6% versus 2.6%. That’s the reply rate gap between the top 10% of outbound campaigns and the median, across email, LinkedIn, and calls combined. The top performers aren’t sending more. They’re sending less, to fewer people, with a reason to reach out already in hand.

We pulled data from 586,310 campaigns run by 52,000 teams to find out what actually separates top outbound campaigns from the rest. The answer isn’t a single trick or a better subject line. It’s a set of habits around list size, signal timing, channel mix, and sending setup that compound into a reply rate 5.6x higher than average.

In this article, I’ll walk through the exact metrics that define the top 10%, side by side with the median, so you can see where your own campaigns stand. Then I’ll break down the seven habits behind those numbers and give you a checklist to run before your next launch.

Median vs top 10%, side by side

Every row below comes from the same dataset: 586,310 campaigns from 52,000 teams, covering 412.6M messages and 1.9M calls analyzed between October 2025 and November 2026.

Metric

Median campaign

Top 10% campaign

Reply rate across all channels

2.6%

14.6%

Leads in the campaign

410

42

Starts from a signal

1.4% of campaigns

38% of campaigns

Channels used

1 (email)

3 (email, LinkedIn, call)

Has a warm call step

9%

27%

Uses Liquid or spin syntax

4%

33%

CCs a second stakeholder

2.4%

14%

Uses AI somewhere

57%

61%

Fully AI-written emails

1.0%

0.2%

Steps / delay between steps

4 steps, 3 days apart

3 steps, 1 day apart

Emails per inbox per day

58

17

Custom tracking domain

51%

88%

Warm-up on

61%

93%

Source: lemlist internal data from its users.

7 habits of the top 10%

Small lists

The median campaign targets 410 leads. The top 10% targets 42. A smaller list forces you to pick accounts that fit your ICP and write messages that reference something specific about each one. When every lead was chosen for a reason, the reply rate reflects it.

A signal behind the campaign

Only 1.4% of median campaigns start from a buying signal. In the top 10%, that number is 38%. A signal (a new hire, a funding round, a tech stack change) gives you a reason to reach out now, not a reason to reach out. That timing context is what separates a relevant message from a generic one.

Three channels and a warm call

Median campaigns use one channel: email. Top performers use three: email, LinkedIn, and calls. 27% of top 10% campaigns include a warm call step, compared to 9% at the median. Adding a call after an email open or a LinkedIn visit turns a passive touchpoint into a live conversation.

Context in the message, not variables

Only 4% of median campaigns use Liquid syntax or spin syntax. In the top 10%, 33% do. Liquid syntax lets you write conditional blocks that change the message based on the lead’s role, industry, or signal, so the email reads like it was written for one person. That goes well beyond swapping in a first name or company with basic email merge tags.

A second stakeholder in CC

Top 10% campaigns CC a second stakeholder 14% of the time. The median does it 2.4% of the time. Adding a CTO when you email a VP of Engineering, or a Head of Sales when you email a CRO, creates internal visibility. It also signals that you did your homework on the org chart.

Fewer steps, closer together

The median campaign runs 4 steps spaced 3 days apart. The top 10% runs 3 steps spaced 1 day apart. Shorter sequences with tighter spacing keep momentum. Email-only campaigns need 312 touches per meeting booked, multichannel campaigns need 118, and top 10% campaigns need 41. For a deeper look at how step count affects meetings, see the breakdown of touches per meeting.

A protected sending setup

Top 10% campaigns send 17 emails per inbox per day. The median sends 58. That volume difference matters because inbox providers throttle or flag senders who push too many messages from a single mailbox. Beyond volume, 88% of top performers use a custom tracking domain (vs. 51% at the median) and 93% keep warm-up on (vs. 61%). If you are unsure about safe limits, check the guide on how many emails you can send a day without hurting deliverability.

What doesn’t make the difference

AI usage is almost identical between the two groups: 57% of median campaigns use AI somewhere, compared to 61% of top 10% campaigns. The gap is negligible.

What is different is how AI gets used. Fully AI-written emails appear in 1.0% of median campaigns but only 0.2% of top performers. The top 10% use AI for research, enrichment, and data cleaning, then write (or heavily edit) the actual message themselves. Letting AI draft your entire email saves time but strips out the context and specificity that drive replies. Following cold email best practices still means a human decides what the message says.

A pre-launch checklist

Before you hit send, run through this list. Every item maps to a habit from the top 10%.

  • [ ] Campaign has fewer than 50 leads

  • [ ] Every lead entered the campaign because of a signal (hiring, funding, tech change, job change)

  • [ ] Sequence uses three channels: email, LinkedIn, and call

  • [ ] Emails use Liquid syntax for conditional personalization

  • [ ] A second stakeholder is CC’d where relevant

  • [ ] Sequence has 3 steps, each 1 day apart

  • [ ] Each inbox sends fewer than 20 emails per day

  • [ ] Custom tracking domain is connected

  • [ ] lemwarm is active on every sending mailbox

If you want to compare your current numbers against broader cold email benchmarks, the all-markets averages from lemlist internal data are: 2.72% email reply rate, 6.6% LinkedIn reply rate, 13.8% call connect rate, and 4.07% reply rate across all channels.

Final takeaway

The top 10% of outbound campaigns do not rely on a single trick. They combine tight targeting, signal-based timing, multichannel sequencing, real personalization, and a deliverability setup that keeps every message landing in the inbox. Each habit reinforces the others, and skipping one weakens the rest.

Pick one campaign. Apply the checklist above. Measure the reply rate after 50 leads have completed the sequence, then adjust.

Build your first signal-based sequence in lemlist.

Build cold email campaigns that work

Find verified leads and launch personalized cold email campaigns.

Frequently asked questions

Across all channels, a 14.6% reply rate puts a campaign in the top 10% (all markets). For email alone, the threshold is 12.96%. For LinkedIn, it is 19.89%. For calls, a 34.15% connect rate qualifies.

Top 10% campaigns average 42 leads. The median campaign has 410. Smaller lists let you match each lead to a signal and write messages with real context.

Top 10% campaigns use 3 steps spaced 1 day apart. The median uses 4 steps spaced 3 days apart. Fewer steps with tighter spacing keep the conversation moving. For a deeper look at how step count affects meetings, see the breakdown of touches per meeting.

AI usage is nearly the same in both groups (57% vs. 61%). The difference is that top performers almost never send fully AI-written emails (0.2% vs. 1.0% at the median). They use AI for lead research, data enrichment, and segmentation, then write the outreach themselves.
Rémi Kokabi

Rémi Kokabi

Co-founder @GTM Club

Share this post