Rémi KokabiNovember 19, 20266 min read

Should you put links in cold emails? What lemlist data shows

No. That’s the short answer on links in cold emails, at least for your first message. lemlist data puts it in numbers: campaigns with zero links reply at 3.50% in Europe. Add two or more links and that drops to 1.88%.

Most reps add a link out of habit. A case study here, a calendar there, a website in the signature. Each one feels harmless on its own, but the data says otherwise.

In this article, I’ll walk through what the numbers show across Europe and the US, why links cost you replies, and where calendar links break the pattern. You’ll also get the exact CTAs to use instead, and the settings in lemlist that make this easy to execute without guessing.

Get this right and your first email reads like a message from a person. Get it wrong and it reads like a pitch before the prospect even opens it.

What lemlist data shows

The pattern holds across markets. More links, fewer replies.

Links in email

Email reply rate (Europe)

Email reply rate (US)

0 links

3.50%

2.34%

1 link

2.84%

1.52%

2+ links

1.88%

1.25%

Source: lemlist internal data from its users.

Campaigns with zero links outperform campaigns with one link in both markets. And campaigns with two or more links sit at the bottom everywhere. The rest of world follows the same shape: 3.49% with no link, 2.70% with one, 2.21% with two or more.

This is correlation, not causation. But the gap is wide enough to act on.

Spam filters parse every URL in your message. Tracked links get rewritten through a redirect domain, which adds an unknown URL that filters can flag. Shortened links (bit.ly, tinyurl) are worse because they hide the destination entirely, a pattern shared with phishing emails.

Beyond filters, a link changes the tone of the message. A cold email with no link reads like a conversation. A cold email with a link reads like a pitch. The recipient sees a landing page, a calendar, or a case study and categorizes the email as marketing before they finish reading.

Each additional link compounds both problems. More redirects for filters to inspect, more signals that the email exists to drive a click rather than start a dialogue. If you want to protect your sender reputation long term, the email deliverability guide covers the full picture.

Calendar links are a special case because the data splits by market.

Calendar link

Email reply rate (Europe)

Email reply rate (US)

With calendar link

2.15%

2.29%

Without calendar link

2.99%

1.81%

Source: lemlist internal data from its users.

In Europe, campaigns without a calendar link reply at 2.99%, compared to 2.15% with one. In the US, the opposite happens: campaigns with a calendar link reply at 2.29% versus 1.81% without.

So it depends on where your prospects sit. European buyers may see a calendar link as presumptuous in a first touch. US buyers may appreciate the low-friction path to a meeting. Test it with your audience, and read the full breakdown in calendar link in cold email.

Open tracking works by embedding a tiny image pixel in your email. That pixel is hosted on a tracking domain, which means your message now contains an external resource that filters can inspect.

The data is clear on the cost.

Open tracking

Email reply rate (Europe)

Email reply rate (US)

Off

4.02%

2.47%

On

2.67%

1.70%

Source: lemlist internal data from its users.

Campaigns with open tracking turned off reply at 4.02% in Europe and 2.47% in the US. With open tracking on, those numbers drop to 2.67% and 1.70%.

A custom tracking domain helps reduce the damage. In Europe, campaigns using a custom tracking domain bounce at 6.5%, compared to 9.1% without one. That gap matters when you are sending thousands of emails per month across multiple mailboxes.

Open rates themselves are unreliable because of privacy features in Apple Mail and other clients. The email open rate accuracy article explains why reply rate is a better metric to optimize around.

Links belong in your sequence. They belong after the first cold touch, not inside it.

  • After a prospect replies and asks for more information

  • In a follow-up step sent only to leads who opened or clicked a previous email

  • When sharing a resource the prospect specifically requested

When you do include a link, use the full domain (https://yoursite.com/case-study) instead of a shortener. One link per email. No tracking redirect if you can avoid it.

The goal is to earn the right to send a link by getting a reply first.

If you remove the link, you need a CTA that still moves the conversation forward. The simplest replacement is a question.

  • “Would it help to see how [similar company] handled this?”

  • “Want me to send over a short breakdown?”

  • “Does this sound like something worth 15 minutes?”

Each of these invites a reply instead of a click. The prospect responds, you send the resource in your reply, and the conversation starts on their terms.

An offer to send something works because it creates a micro-commitment. The prospect says yes, you deliver, and the next message has context. That sequence converts better than dropping a link into a void.

For more CTA patterns that work without links, the cold email CTA guide has ready-to-use examples. You can also pair a shorter CTA with a tighter message overall, which the cold email length article covers.

How lemlist helps

lemlist is built for the workflow this article describes.

  • Emails send as plain text by default, so your messages look like real conversations instead of marketing templates

  • Open tracking can be turned off per campaign, giving you control over whether to prioritize deliverability data or reply rates on each sequence

  • Custom tracking domains are supported so that when you do track, the redirect points to your own domain instead of a shared one

  • Conditions let you send a resource link only after a prospect replies or shows engagement, keeping your first touch clean and adding the link in a later step where it belongs

These settings work together. You start with a plain, linkless first email. If the prospect engages, a condition triggers the next step with the resource. If they reply, you respond from the unified inbox with whatever they asked for.

Final takeaway

Strip links from your first cold email. Use a question as your CTA. Add links only in follow-up steps triggered by engagement or in direct replies.

The data backs this up across every market in the dataset. Fewer links, more replies.

Build your first signal-based sequence in lemlist and set it up the right way from step one.

Build cold email campaigns that work

Find verified leads and launch personalized cold email campaigns.

Frequently asked questions

They can. Spam filters inspect every URL in your message, and tracked or shortened links add redirect domains that raise flags. Campaigns with zero links consistently outperform campaigns with one or more links in reply rate across both European and US markets.

A signature link is still a link. It gets parsed by spam filters the same way a link in the body does. If you want to maximize replies on your first email, consider a minimal signature with your name, title, and company name only.

It depends on your market. In Europe, campaigns without a calendar link reply at 2.99% versus 2.15% with one. In the US, campaigns with a calendar link reply at 2.29% versus 1.81% without. Test both versions with your audience.

Yes. Campaigns with open tracking turned off reply at 4.02% in Europe and 2.47% in the US, compared to 2.67% and 1.70% with tracking on. If you need open tracking, use a custom tracking domain to reduce bounces.
Rémi Kokabi

Rémi Kokabi

Co-founder @GTM Club

Share this post